Cramdown Plan of Reorganization in a Commercial Real Estate Case

In a Chapter 11 bankruptcy, a cramdown plan of reorganization in a commercial real estate case usually involves a property owner trying to force an under secured mortgage lender to accept a new note for a reduced principal amount, equal to the mortgaged property value, with modified terms such as an extended maturity and a market rate of interest.

In a Chapter 11 plan, the claims are classified.  For the reorganization plan to be confirmed, each class of claims must vote to accept the plan, or not be impaired under the plan.  Under the Bankruptcy Code, if any class is impaired under the plan, at least one impaired class must vote to accept the plan. If this requirement is met and the plan is fair and equitable, it is possible to confirm the plan over the objection of other, non-accepting classes through cramdown.

Mortgage lenders are often the largest creditor in these bankruptcy cases.  Mortgage lenders block these cramdown plans by using their deficiency claim to control the unsecured creditor class and cause it to vote against the reorganization plan approval. If a bankruptcy debtor cannot get the approval of a reorganization plan, the case may be dismissed and the mortgage lender able to foreclose under state law.

In re Loop 76, LLC, 465 B.R. 525 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 2012), the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel of the Ninth Circuit upheld a Bankruptcy Court decision that a secured lender’s unsecured deficiency claim could be separately classified from the claims of other unsecured creditors.  The decision paves the way for confirming a cramdown plan of reorganization against the lender’s opposition. In the case, the borrower was a single asset real estate debtor.  The court focused on the lender’s access to third-party guarantees to support an evidentiary conclusion that its claim was not substantially similar to other unsecured creditors.

The court decision affects lenders.  The court assessed the similarity of the claims, and did not base its decision on their respective right and priority to the debtor’s assets.

In a single asset real estate case, an under secured mortgage lender’s deficiency claim will usually be greater than other unsecured claims against the debtor.  Other unsecured claims may consist of trade payables.  If there is just one class of unsecured claims, the lender will control the unsecured class, vote to reject the plan in the secured and unsecured classes.  The debtor is not able to proceed to cramdown.

To get around not being able to go to cramdown, the debtor may create a separate class for the lender’s deficiency claim.  The non-lender unsecured creditors may vote in a separate class to accept the plan. The lender may attack such a classification scheme.  The debtor seeks to gain an unfair advantage in what is actually a two-party dispute between the lender and the borrower.  The debtor argues its deficiency claim is not dissimilar to other unsecured claims, and there is no legitimate business justification for a separate classification.

For Chapter 11 bankruptcy questions, contact an experienced New York bankruptcy attorney.

Table of Contents

Contact Us

Featured Blog Posts

What is IRS? IRS Tax and Audit Guide: Role of Internal Revenue Service in Enforcing Federal Tax Laws. Contact the IRS for Federal Tax Return, Form W-9 and More.

Introduction to What is IRS (Internal Revenue Service) The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is a critical agency within the United States responsible for administering and enforcing the federal tax laws for the United States government. It plays a pivotal role in funding essential public services and supporting the nation’s economic

Read More »

Where is my New York State tax refund?

Introduction When tax season comes to a close, many New Yorkers eagerly anticipate receiving their state tax refunds. It’s a well-deserved reward for diligent taxpayers, providing a financial boost that can be used for various purposes. In this article, we will explore the ins and outs of the New York

Read More »

Miami Florida Tax Articles

Florida Tax Guide: Is Social Security Taxed in Florida? Federal Tax Benefits of Retiring in the State of Florida 2023

Florida Tax Guide: Is Social Security Taxed in Florida? Federal Tax Benefits of Retiring in the State of Florida 2023

Social Security benefits serve as a vital source of income for many retirees. As individuals near their golden years, understanding the nuances of Social Security taxation becomes crucial. In this

September 11, 2023
Florida Tax Information for Taxpayers and Tax Professionals: Do I Need to File State Income Taxes in Florida? Role of Florida Department of Revenue

Florida Tax Information for Taxpayers and Tax Professionals: Do I Need to File State Income Taxes in Florida? Role of Florida Department of Revenue

Are you a resident of the Sunshine State wondering about your state tax obligations? Understanding whether you need to file state taxes in Florida is essential to ensure compliance with

August 28, 2023
Florida State Tax Rate 2023: Is There An Income Tax in Florida? Everything You Need To Know About Florida Tax. Florida Income Tax Calculator

Florida State Tax Rate 2023: Is There An Income Tax in Florida? Everything You Need To Know About Florida Tax. Florida Income Tax Calculator

In a world where state income taxes are the norm, Florida stands out as a haven for residents seeking a reprieve from this financial burden. The Sunshine State has gained

August 18, 2023

Have More Questions?

If you have not found the Tax & Accounting answers you are looking for, feel free to search here and browse our article catalog!